Puerto Rico Case Commentaries

Dirig v. State: Negligence Instructions Can Fundamentally Undermine a Knowing-Endangerment Prosecution

Date: Nov 18, 2026

Dirig v. State: Negligence Instructions Can Fundamentally Undermine a Knowing-Endangerment Prosecution Supreme Court of Indiana · Case No. 26S-CR-399 · November 16, 2026 Opinion by Justice Molter,...

Tier 6-to-Tier 4 Pension Transfers: Comptroller May Use Effective Transfer Date to Limit Contribution Refunds

Date: Nov 17, 2026

Tier 6-to-Tier 4 Pension Transfers: Comptroller May Use Effective Transfer Date to Limit Contribution Refunds Case: Matter of Pasinkoff v New York State & Local Retirement Sys., 2026 NY Slip Op 06599...

Long COVID Claims: No Separate Amendment for Continuing Symptoms, but Work-Related Causation Remains Essential

Date: Nov 17, 2026

Long COVID Claims: No Separate Amendment for Continuing Symptoms, but Work-Related Causation Remains Essential Case: Matter of Hahnenfeld v Good Samaritan Hosp., 2026 NY Slip Op 06601 Court:...

Custody Modification: Appellate Review May Supply a Missing Changed-Circumstances Finding

Date: Nov 17, 2026

Custody Modification: Appellate Review May Supply a Missing Changed-Circumstances Finding Matter of Scott E. v Annette D., 2026 NY Slip Op 06597, Appellate Division, Third Department, November 12,...

SEQRA and Synthetic Turf: A Documented Assessment of Chemical Risks Can Support a Negative Declaration

Date: Nov 17, 2026

SEQRA and Synthetic Turf: A Documented Assessment of Chemical Risks Can Support a Negative Declaration Case: In the Matter of Zero Waste Ithaca v Ithaca City Planning & Development Board et al....

Known Safe Retreat Defeats Entitlement to a Deadly-Force Self-Defense Instruction

Date: Nov 17, 2026

Known Safe Retreat Defeats Entitlement to a Deadly-Force Self-Defense Instruction Case: Martin v. State Court: Supreme Court of Delaware Decision date: November 12, 2026 Docket: No. 121, 2025...

Unpaid Retention Compensation Can Be Covered Back Pay Rather Than Excluded Severance

Date: Nov 17, 2026

Unpaid Retention Compensation Can Be Covered “Back Pay” Rather Than Excluded Severance Commentary on Carpenter v. Twin City Fire, No. 25-10679, United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit,...

Wyoming’s Repeat-Theft Enhancement: Failure to Raise Qualifying-Fact Disputes Forfeits Jury Determination

Date: Nov 17, 2026

Wyoming’s Repeat-Theft Enhancement: Failure to Raise Qualifying-Fact Disputes Forfeits Jury Determination Case: Jason William Ming v. The State of Wyoming Citation: 2026 WY 120 Court: Supreme Court...

Unilateral Attacks Do Not Alone Require Judicial Recusal: Sentencing and Impartiality in United States v. William Richardson

Date: Nov 17, 2026

Unilateral Attacks Do Not Alone Require Judicial Recusal: Sentencing and Impartiality in United States v. William Richardson Court: United States Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit Decided:...

People v Morrison: Psychiatric-Examination Statements Cannot Supply the Basis for a Justification Defense

Date: Nov 17, 2026

People v Morrison: Psychiatric-Examination Statements Cannot Supply the Basis for a Justification Defense 2026 NY Slip Op 06593 — Appellate Division, Third Department — November 12, 2026 This...

Charge-Based Juror Bias Requires Unequivocal Rehabilitation, Not General Assurances of Following Instructions

Date: Nov 17, 2026

Charge-Based Juror Bias Requires Unequivocal Rehabilitation, Not General Assurances of Following Instructions Case: People v Mulverhill, 2026 NY Slip Op 06588 Court: Supreme Court of New York,...

Idaho Construction Contracts With Unregistered Contractors Are Voidable at the Project Owner’s Election, Not Void

Date: Nov 17, 2026

Idaho Construction Contracts With Unregistered Contractors Are Voidable at the Project Owner’s Election, Not Void Case: Kumm v. Work Shops & Sons Court: Supreme Court of Idaho Docket: No. 53040...

Corroborated Anonymous Drug Tips and Third-Party Flight: Probable Cause Defeats a False-Arrest Claim

Date: Nov 17, 2026

Corroborated Anonymous Drug Tips and Third-Party Flight: Probable Cause Defeats a False-Arrest Claim Case: Colburn Clifton Gooden Kelly v. Deputy Cody Jett, No. 24-10553 Court: United States Court of...

Abusive Sexual Contact: Circumstantial Proof of Intent and Harmless Exposure to Forfeiture Allegations

Date: Nov 17, 2026

Abusive Sexual Contact: Circumstantial Proof of Intent and Harmless Exposure to Forfeiture Allegations Case: United States v. Justin Dale Sigmon Court: United States Court of Appeals for the Eleventh...

Misdemeanor Conversion Has No Automatic $1,000 Restitution Cap, but Recovery Must Follow the Offense of Conviction

Date: Nov 17, 2026

Misdemeanor Conversion Has No Automatic $1,000 Restitution Cap, but Recovery Must Follow the Offense of Conviction Case: United States v. Malakhov, No. 25-1319-cr Court: United States Court of...

Class Certification After Dunn: En Banc Denial Preserves Contested Rules on Damages Models and Administrative Feasibility

Date: Nov 17, 2026

Class Certification After Dunn: En Banc Denial Preserves Contested Rules on Damages Models and Administrative Feasibility Case: Dunn v. Santa Fe Natural Tobacco Company Court: United States Court of...

On-Farm Manure Removal as Secondary Agriculture and the Threshold Burden to Prove FLSA Employment

Date: Nov 17, 2026

On-Farm Manure Removal as Secondary Agriculture and the Threshold Burden to Prove FLSA Employment Case: Porter v. T.J. Crowder and Sons, No. 25-1310 Court: United States Court of Appeals for the...

Failure to Seek a Sentencing Continuance: Ineffective Assistance Requires a Reasonable Probability of a Lower Sentence

Date: Nov 17, 2026

Failure to Seek a Sentencing Continuance: Ineffective Assistance Requires a Reasonable Probability of a Lower Sentence United States v. Ukashat, No. 26-4108, United States Court of Appeals for the...

Black Lung Claims: Improved Later Pulmonary Tests Cannot Control Solely Because They Are More Recent

Date: Nov 17, 2026

Black Lung Claims: Improved Later Pulmonary Tests Cannot Control Solely Because They Are More Recent Case: Lodestar Energy, Inc. v. OWCP, No. 25-3840 Court: United States Court of Appeals for the...

People v. Johnson: Plain-Error Review After Guilty Pleas and the Limits of Retrospective Fitness Hearings

Date: Nov 17, 2026

People v. Johnson: Plain-Error Review After Guilty Pleas and the Limits of Retrospective Fitness Hearings Supreme Court of Illinois | 2026 IL 130932 | November 12, 2026 1. Introduction People v....